🎯 From Listings to Loyalty: Crafting a Strong Brand on Walmart.com Join our expert webinar with Bellavix & TargetBay 🚀 Spots are limited

Get access to our complete email template library for the Beauty & Cosmetics industry

Food Brands Marketing Emails

QUARTERLY INDUSTRY BENCHMARK

Food, Tea, and Coffee Brands Email Marketing Report
Q1 2025 (Jan-March)

The Data-Backed Strategies Behind Top Brands

We analyzed 400+ email campaigns from popular Food, Tea, and Coffee brands over 3 months. This playbook highlights key trends in send times, frequency, subject lines, and CTAs to help you optimize your email campaigns.

Disclaimer

This report is based on data collected from publicly available email campaigns sent by Food, Tea, and Coffee brands between January and March 2025 to a random subscriber. While we strive for accuracy in our analysis, individual results may vary based on specific audience demographics, market conditions, and other factors. The strategies outlined in this report should be tested and adapted to your unique business needs. TargetBay is not affiliated with any of the brands mentioned in this report unless explicitly stated. All trademarks and brand names are the property of their respective owners.

The Brands We Analyzed

Our comprehensive analysis covers leading eCommerce brands in the Food, Tea, and Coffee industry. We’ve tracked their email marketing strategies to identify trends and best practices. Here are the brands we analyzed.
foodsaver
mccormick
skinnytaste
proof
eater
rxbar
Brand
Emails Sent
Emails in Inbox
Emails in SPAM
Anastasia Beverly Hills
28
28
-
Aveda
145
136
9
Avon
44
-
44
Bareminerals
97
97
-
Bath & Body Works
114
114
-
Bluemercury
48
48
-
Bobbiebrown.com
99
99
-
Burt's Bees
28
28
-
Charlotte Tilbury Beauty
79
79
-
Clinique
130
130
-
Colourpop
65
65
-
Cover Girl Cosmetics
5
5
-
Dr.Jart
67
67
-
E.L.F. Cosmetics
41
41
-
Estee Lauder
124
124
-
Glossier
53
53
-
Juvia
20
20
-
Kylie Cosmetics
30
4
26
Laura Mericer Cosmetics
67
67
-
Maybelline
14
14
-
Moroccanoil
61
61
-
Morphe
7
7
-
Oribe Hair Care
33
30
3
Ouai
33
33
-
Rarebeauty
23
23
-
Tarte
45
45
-
The Body Shop America
16
15
1
Too Faced Cosmetics
13
13
-
Ulta Beauty
13
13
-
WetNWild Beauty
8
5
3

Key Data Insights from Food Industry Email Campaigns

clock icon

1. Email Send Time & Days

food info

🔍 Strategies Behind Email Send Times

message icon

3. Email Placement: Inbox vs. Spam

Brands like Eater, Skinnytaste, Lindt, and RxBar have 100% of their emails landing in the inbox.

Most brands, except a few like HotelChocolat and McCormick, are avoiding spam folders with rates close to 0%. This could be due to strong deliverability practices, such as proper list segmentation, using recognizable sending addresses, and optimizing content for both engagement and compliance with email best practices.

Brands that send emails consistently (like Skinnytaste and Eater) likely build a strong reputation with email service providers, contributing to a high inbox placement.

The low spam rate for these brands suggests they focus on clean lists, avoid spam trigger words, and use authenticated sending infrastructure (SPF/DKIM).

Inbox icon

99.52%

Average inbox rate

SPAM email icon

0.48%

Average Spam Rate

Total email icon

1,550

Total Emails Analyzed

food info

What Makes People Click and Open Your Email?

Email Subject Lines That Stood Out

Lindtusa

Mccormick

Rxbar

Get Inspired

Download Subject Line Inspirations from All Brands

message icon

5. Preview Text: The Secret Ingredient

Similar to subject lines, preview texts also emphasize urgency with phrases like “limited time offer,” which prompt quick action from the recipients.

A lot of preview texts highlight specific promotions or discounts, such as “Save 20%” or “Exclusive deals,” motivating recipients to open the email to avail themselves of offers.

Brands also encourage exploration and discovery, often using phrases like “find your new favorite flavor,” which piques curiosity and encourages engagement.

Email Preview Text Inspirations

McCormick

email icon

6. Email Types: What Works Best?

The Food, Tea, and Coffee industry appears to predominantly focus on Other Category of Emails. It include product launches, holiday/seasonal emails, and thematic emails.
This suggests that food brands rely on specific events, launches, and seasonal campaigns to engage their audience. Relationship building and educational content emails are less common, with promotional emails having a minimal presence.

Note: Other email types include product launches, Holiday and seasonal emails, and thematic email types.

Promotions icon

1.44%

Promotional

Relationship building icon

2.64%

Relationship Building

Educational icon

1.68%

Educational

Seasonal icon

94.23%

Other

mouse pointer icon

7. CTA Strategies: What Drives Conversions?

The food industry’s email strategies are largely centered around Subscription-based Engagement (via sign-up CTAs) and Direct Sales (via shop and product-focused CTAs).

“Sign up” (e.g., “Sign up for the Eater Dallas newsletter”) is widely used, particularly for newsletters and content subscriptions.

“Shop now” / “SHOP ONLINE” is commonly used by brands promoting their products.

“SHOP ALL” appears frequently in brands like RXBar, promoting a range of products.

Most Used CTAs by Each Brand

Improve Your Email Inbox Placement Rate Today!

Book a free consultation call.

After analyzing 400+ email campaigns from top eCommerce brands in the Food, Tea, and Coffee Industry, here are the common patterns we found.

Lessons from the Best: Key Takeaways for Email Marketers

Based on our analysis of the Food, Tea, and Coffee industry’s email marketing, we’ve identified several key strategies to achieve results across brands of all sizes.

1. Optimize Send Times Based on Audience Behavior

The data suggests emails are being sent at consistent times (e.g., 10 AM - 2 PM), likely to align with consumer routines (e.g., mid-morning or post-lunch engagement).

2. Balance Promotional and Relationship-Building Content

While many emails contain promotional offers (e.g., "50% Off"), there is a noticeable trend in content that encourages relationship-building, such as newsletters or recipe content. A good strategy is maintaining a 60/40 balance between promotional and value-adding emails.

3. Utilize Geographically Targeted Content

Brands like Eater send location-specific content (e.g., "Eater Dallas newsletter"), suggesting that location-based segmentation increases relevance and engagement. Use geographic segmentation to send personalized local content, improving open rates.

4. Create Urgency with Time-Sensitive Offers

Several brands use urgency to drive immediate action (e.g., "Last Chance," "Shop now for a limited time"). Use time-sensitive offers to create a sense of urgency and push for quicker conversions.

5. Use Clear and Actionable Call-to-Actions (CTAs)

Most CTAs such as "Sign Up Now" and "Shop Now" are direct and action-oriented. To increase engagement, CTAs should always be clear, actionable, and strategically placed, encouraging immediate action from the reader.

Implementing These Insights in Your Email Strategy

Turning these insights into actionable strategies requires a systematic approach. Here’s how to implement these findings in your Food Industry brand’s email marketing program:

Recommended Strategies

1. Audit Your Current Performance

Review past email campaigns, analyzing open rates, click-through rates (CTR), and conversions. Compare results to industry benchmarks to identify areas for improvement, such as subject lines, send times, or CTA effectiveness. Prioritize adjustments that can significantly boost engagement.

2. Develop a Testing Calendar

Create a plan to test different email elements, such as send times, subject lines, preview text, and CTAs. Track performance and refine your strategy based on testing results. For example, test sending emails at 11 AM or 1 PM to optimize open rates and conversions.

3. Refine Your Segmentation

Use customer data to segment your audience more granularly based on behaviors, purchases, and engagement. Tailor content to each segment, such as sending personalized recipes to frequent buyers or special offers to new subscribers. This increases the relevance of your emails and improves engagement.

4. Implement Urgency & FOMO Strategies

Speak urgency-driven language like “Last Chance” or “Ends Tonight” in your subject lines and CTAs. These time-sensitive offers encourage recipients to act quickly, boosting conversions. Track how this strategy impacts the performance of your campaigns.

Ready to implement these strategies in real time?

Food, Tea, and Coffee Industry Email Templates That Stood Out

Q1: Email Template Snapshots

Check Out More Email Templates from the Food Industry!

Complete repository of email templates.

Final Thoughts

In Q1 2025, email marketing in the Food, Tea, and Coffee industry has seen a clear emphasis on personalized engagement, location-based targeting, and urgency-driven offers. Brands are focusing heavily on building relationships with subscribers through newsletters and engaging content such as recipes.

With promotional emails offering limited-time deals, the industry continues to capitalize on FOMO (fear of missing out) strategies.

Moving forward, we can expect an increased integration of data-driven personalization, where emails will become more tailored to consumer behavior and preferences. Mobile-optimized, responsive emails will remain crucial as the industry adapts to evolving consumer expectations and browsing habits.