🎯 From Listings to Loyalty: Crafting a Strong Brand on Walmart.com Join our expert webinar with Bellavix & TargetBay 🚀 Spots are limited

Get access to our complete email template library for the Beauty & Cosmetics industry

Health & Supplement Brands Marketing Emails

QUARTERLY INDUSTRY BENCHMARK

Health & Supplement Brands Email Marketing Report
Q1 2025 (Jan-March)

The Data-Backed Strategies Behind Top Brands

We analyzed 100+ email campaigns from popular Health & Supplement brands over 3 months. This playbook highlights key trends in send times, frequency, subject lines, and CTAs to help you optimize your email campaigns.

Disclaimer

This report is based on data collected from publicly available email campaigns sent by Health & Supplement brands between January and March 2025 to a random subscriber. While we strive for accuracy in our analysis, individual results may vary based on specific audience demographics, market conditions, and other factors. The strategies outlined in this report should be tested and adapted to your unique business needs. TargetBay is not affiliated with any of the brands mentioned in this report unless explicitly stated. All trademarks and brand names are the property of their respective owners.

The Brands We Analyzed

Our comprehensive analysis covers leading eCommerce brands in the Health & Supplement industry. We’ve tracked their email marketing strategies to identify trends and best practices. Here are the brands we analyzed.
bistomd
orgain
gnc
iherb
piping rock
Brand
Emails Sent
Emails in Inbox
Emails in SPAM
Anastasia Beverly Hills
28
28
-
Aveda
145
136
9
Avon
44
-
44
Bareminerals
97
97
-
Bath & Body Works
114
114
-
Bluemercury
48
48
-
Bobbiebrown.com
99
99
-
Burt's Bees
28
28
-
Charlotte Tilbury Beauty
79
79
-
Clinique
130
130
-
Colourpop
65
65
-
Cover Girl Cosmetics
5
5
-
Dr.Jart
67
67
-
E.L.F. Cosmetics
41
41
-
Estee Lauder
124
124
-
Glossier
53
53
-
Juvia
20
20
-
Kylie Cosmetics
30
4
26
Laura Mericer Cosmetics
67
67
-
Maybelline
14
14
-
Moroccanoil
61
61
-
Morphe
7
7
-
Oribe Hair Care
33
30
3
Ouai
33
33
-
Rarebeauty
23
23
-
Tarte
45
45
-
The Body Shop America
16
15
1
Too Faced Cosmetics
13
13
-
Ulta Beauty
13
13
-
WetNWild Beauty
8
5
3

Key Data Insights from Health Industry Email Campaigns

clock icon

1. Email Send Time & Days

email send times

🔍 Strategies Behind Email Send Times

message icon

3. Email Placement: Inbox vs. Spam

GNC, Orgain, PipingRock, iHerb all have an inbox rate of 100%

These brands may be following best practices to ensure high deliverability, such as consistent sending patterns, proper email authentication, and highly engaging content.

✅ Brands like GNC, Orgain, and iHerb may be sending emails at optimal times and maintaining consistent frequency, which builds trust with email providers.

Using personalized subject lines, preview text, and maintaining a healthy text-to-image ratio could be contributing factors for inbox placement.

Email Authentication: Proper DKIM and SPF records might be in place to ensure emails are authenticated correctly, avoiding spam filters.

Inbox icon

84.82%

Average inbox rate

SPAM email icon

15.18%

Average Spam Rate

Total email icon

112

Total Emails Analyzed

subject line

What Makes People Click and Open Your Email?

Email Subject Lines That Stood Out

GNC

Orgain

PipingRock

Get Inspired

Download Subject Line Inspirations from All Brands

message icon

5. Preview Text: The Secret Ingredient

Words like “savings,” “deals,” “50% off,” and “save” are frequently used to reinforce the urgency and value mentioned in the subject line.

Preview texts often highlight health-related topics, such as “health,” “wellness,” “vitamins,” and “essential oils.”

This reinforces the brand’s positioning in the health space and appeals to health-conscious customers.

Many preview texts include specific product mentions, such as “Oxyshred sale,” “ShakeUp! Rewards,” and “Quality Supplements.” These are designed to directly inform the subscriber about the products and offers inside, helping to drive interest.

Email Preview Text Inspirations

GNC

Orgain

email icon

6. Email Types: What Works Best?

Promotional Emails are the most common, constituting about 67% of all emails.

These emails are likely focused on offering discounts, deals, and special offers, with brands aiming to drive immediate sales and actions.
Other category emails focus on engaging the audience with new products or timely content tied to specific events or seasons.

This distribution suggests that brands are primarily focusing on promotional strategies, followed by seasonal and thematic content to drive sales.

Educational content is less emphasized, possibly reserved for more specialized campaigns.

Note: Other email types include product launches, Holiday and seasonal emails, and thematic email types.

Promotions icon

66.96%

Promotional

Relationship building icon

-

Relationship Building

Educational icon

2.68%

Educational

Seasonal icon

30.36%

Other

mouse pointer icon

7. CTA Strategies: What Drives Conversions?

“SHOP NOW” (appearing 46 times) is the most common CTA, indicating a strong emphasis on driving immediate action to purchase.

“CRAZY DEALS” and “DEALS” are also frequently used, focusing on promoting special offers and discounts.

“LEARN MORE” is used occasionally, suggesting a focus on educating customers about the product or brand, but it’s less prevalent compared to purchase-driven CTAs.

Most Used CTAs by Each Brand

Improve Your Email Inbox Placement Rate Today!

Book a free consultation call.

After analyzing 100+ email campaigns from the top eCommerce brands in the Health & Supplement Industry, here are the common patterns we found.

Lessons from the Best: Key Takeaways for Email Marketers

Based on our analysis of the Health & Supplement industry’s email marketing, we’ve identified several key strategies to achieve results across brands of all sizes.

1. Optimize Send Times for Your Audience

Health brands should test send times to optimize for engagement, as timing can vary based on the customer base. The industry trends show varied engagement times.

2. Focus on Promotions with Urgency

Many health brands focus heavily on promotional emails, especially those that create a sense of urgency, such as "Ends Soon", "Limited Time Offer", or "Last Chance". Urgency works effectively in the health space to encourage quick actions.

3. Balance Sales and Relationship-Building Content

Successful brands in the health space maintain a balance between promotional and relationship-building emails. Health-focused emails often include not just offers, but also content around health benefits, product education, or user testimonials.

4. Include Clear and Actionable CTAs

The most effective CTAs in the health industry encourage immediate action, such as "Shop Now," "Sign Up," "Save Now," or "Learn More." Clear, concise, and urgent CTAs help drive conversions and increase customer engagement.

5. Promote Subscription and Loyalty Programs

Many health brands focus on promoting subscription-based offers or rewards programs, like "Earn Points" or "Subscribe & Save." This not only encourages customer retention but also increases lifetime value by making it easier for customers to reorder products they use frequently.

Implementing These Insights in Your Email Strategy

Turning these insights into actionable strategies requires a systematic approach. Here’s how to implement these findings in your Health Industry brand’s email marketing program:

Recommended Strategies

1. Audit Your Current Performance

Analyze your current email metrics, including open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates. Compare these metrics against industry benchmarks for the Health & Supplement industry. Identify gaps in your strategy, such as low engagement with certain email types or segments.

2. Refine Your Segmentation

Move beyond basic demographics and implement granular audience segmentation based on purchase behavior, engagement levels, and product preferences. Use insights from past purchases and browsing history to deliver personalized offers, recommendations, and content to each subscriber.

3. Optimize for Mobile:

Ensure that your email templates are mobile-friendly. With over 60% of emails opened on mobile devices, your content must be fully responsive. Simplify email designs for a smooth reading experience on smaller screens. This will boost user engagement, as many health-focused subscribers will check emails on the go.

4. Include Clear, Urgent CTAs

Write CTAs that are clear, concise, and action-oriented. Use language that creates urgency, such as “Shop Now,” “Hurry, Offer Ends Soon,” or “Sign Up Today.” This approach not only prompts immediate action but also plays into the urgency strategy that is effective in the Health & Supplement industry for promotions and limited-time offers.

Ready to implement these strategies in real time?

Health Email Templates That Stood Out

Q1: Email Template Snapshots

Check Out More Email Templates from the Health Industry!

Complete repository of email templates.

Final Thoughts

In Q1 of 2025, email marketing in the health industry has focused primarily on promotions and urgency.

Health brands like GNC, Orgain, and iHerb have heavily leveraged discounts, BOGO offers, and time-sensitive deals to engage subscribers and drive conversions. The use of personalized content, mobile optimization, and clear CTAs has been critical in maximizing engagement.

Moving forward, we can expect continued emphasis on personalization and targeted content, as well as increased automation and segmentation to refine customer interactions. The integration of AI-driven personalization and data-driven strategies will likely dominate the future of health-related email marketing.